The Insurance Shop
Independent Insurance Agency Serving Michigan
We help individuals, families & small businesses throughout Michigan find the right insurance coverage without the hassle. Whether you need a policy for your car, home, boat, life, or business, we’ll guide you every step of the way. As a local, independent agency, we offer real conversations, custom plans & competitive rates from top carriers you can trust.
Why Work With Us
Local Experts.
Real Relationships. Proven Service.
We’re
not a call center. We’re
your neighbors – a real team based in East Jordan that understands the unique needs of living, working & doing business in Michigan. We take the time to get to know you, explain your options, and
match you with coverage that truly fits. Whether you’re insuring your first car, upgrading your home, or managing a seasonal business, we’re here with
dependable support.
What Sets Us Apart:
- Over 30 years of experience helping Michigan clients
- Independent, so we shop multiple carriers for better options & better rates
- Local team that understands seasonal risks, tourist traffic & lake life
- Personalized support whenever you need it – not just when you buy a policy



Coverage Built for Life in Michigan From family homes to charter businesses, we help protect what matters most.
Bed & Breakfast Insurance
Custom coverage for Michigan innkeepers. We’re a trusted provider for B&Bs across the state, offering tailored protection for guest stays, property, liability & business income.
Charter Boat Insurance
Specialized marine insurance designed for tour boats, fishing charters & water-based businesses. We understand the unique risks of operating on Michigan’s lakes.
Homeowners Insurance
Protection for your home, your belongings & the people under your roof. We’ll help you choose the right plan for year-round or seasonal living.
Auto Insurance
Coverage for the road ahead. Whether you're commuting daily or driving the scenic route, we’ll help you find the right plan for your car or truck.
Watercraft Insurance
From pontoons to personal watercraft, we provide insurance that fits your time on the water. Hull, liability & seasonal use coverage available.
Commercial Insurance
Coverage for small businesses of all kinds – retail, service, contractors & more. Let’s build a custom plan to help you operate with confidence.
Health Insurance
Individual & family health plans that fit your lifestyle, including ACA marketplace options, short-term medical, and small group coverage.
Life Insurance
Plan ahead with coverage that supports your family’s financial future. Choose from term, whole & permanent life insurance options.
Contact Us
Have a question or not sure what coverage you need? We’re local, easy to reach & happy to help — no pressure, just straight answers.
What Our Clients Are Saying
-
Randy DesRosiers
"Brenda is awesome! I have my 43' yacht and a smaller 20' jet boat insured with The Insurance Shop and it has been an awesome experience!"
MashIt -
Lisa Ashton
"Nikki and staff are always very helpful. They have the best prices, right on any claims we might have and willing to go the extra mile. We have been a client for over 27 years. My husband has been client for over 45 years. Our kids even use them. The Insurance Shop is the best."
FabuFit -
Adam Johnson
"The entire staff at The Insurance Shop in East Jordan have been super helpful anytime that I have called with questions. Jackie is my agent and has always gone above and beyond. She has always returned phone calls promptly. It’s a no worries experience."
YesSuits Kate Chanda
"We have used the Insurance Shop for 22 years and we have always been taken care of with kindness, professionalism, and care. We are always talking to a person and issues are resolved quickly and accurately. We wouldn’t even consider going through a different insurance provider."
Button
Proud to Serve the Communities Around Us
Local Matters
From East Jordan to Charlevoix, Petoskey, Boyne City & beyond – we know the people, the weather, and the local risks. We’re part of this community, and we’re proud to help protect the homes, vehicles & businesses that make it great.

Stay informed
Helpful Insurance Tips from Our Team
- How Much Home Insurance Do You Really Need in Michigan?
- What to Know Before Insuring Your Charter Boat
- 5 Ways to Lower Auto Insurance Costs for New Drivers
-
The Financial Advantages of Life Insurance Beyond Protection
Rethinking Life Insurance: Beyond a Safety NetMany view life insurance solely as a financial safety net for loved ones after passing. However, the potential of life insurance extends far beyond...Read more -
How to Prepare Your Charter Boat for an Insurance Inspection
If you’re insuring your charter boat in Michigan, there’s a good chance your provider will request a vessel inspection — especially if you’re operating commercially. These inspections help insurers...Read more